Haunted by the memory of Walter Holderlin, a soldier he killed during World War I, French musician Paul Renard (Phillips Holmes) confesses to a priest (Frank Sheridan), who grants him absolution. Using the address on a letter he found on the dead man's body, Paul then travels to Germany to find his family.
As anti-French sentiment continues to permeate Germany, Dr. Holderlin (Lionel Barrymore) initially refuses to welcome Paul into his home, but changes his mind when his son's fiancée Elsa identifies him as the man who has been leaving flowers on Walter's grave. Rather than reveal the real connection between them, Paul tells the Holderlin family he was a friend of their son, who attended the same musical conservatory he did.
Although the hostile townspeople and local gossips disapprove, the Holderlins befriend Paul, who finds himself falling in love with Elsa (Nancy Carroll). When she shows Paul her former fiancé's bedroom, he becomes distraught and tells her the truth. She convinces him not to confess to Walter's parents, who have embraced him as their second son, and Paul agrees to forego easing his conscience and stays with his adopted family. Dr. Holderlin presents Walter's violin to Paul, who plays it while Elsa accompanies him on the piano.
The film's original title, The Man I Killed, was changed to The Fifth Commandment to avoid giving "wrong impressions in the minds of the public about the character of the story." It ultimately was released as Broken Lullaby.
40 what about the recon guy? the one holding his family photograph when he bled out? what about the old man helping James who has two beautiful daughters and left his family 13 years ago?
真敢拍啊这内容竟然很贴合当下，可惜长度不够，BOSS太弱，建议拍成电视剧！
勉强6.0/10 所以呢？你只是搞定了一个下游承包商，即便是他做的决定，但整体的组织策划者呢？本这个角色怎么就义无反顾一把小手枪就跟你一起清算了？有些段落可以看出来剪的问题，但大问题还是剧本不尽如人意。22/04/26
本片是派派Chris Pine和本福斯特继《怒海救援》、《赴汤蹈火》后第三次合作。派派年纪大了也开始接自己的《John Wick》了，类似基努里维斯、连姆尼森的中年硬汉，希望能够通过动作片再次向好莱坞证明：我还没老，我还能打！剧情来说依然是美国退伍老兵被坑然后复仇的故事，但是节奏把握的非常到位，103分钟毫无拖泥带水，重现了谍影重重般的追杀、反侦察？真实肉搏，让我这个动作片爱好者大呼过瘾。最后赞一下亚马逊，这片子本来美国时间4月1号上线的，但是资源提前一天流出了，今天就能在家同步北美院线爽上流媒体4K真是太爽了哈哈哈。
最后反转的无力，真是主角光环，就是不死。剧情倒是不错，流感疫苗，黑美国政府。
典型的想法大于能力，能感觉出来很努力的想拍一部好电影，但是，剧情硬伤太多，推情绪的节奏感又混乱，还是那句：烂编剧不分国界
胜在困境的营造有真实感，所有人也都是困兽犹斗，无论杀人和被杀皆如此。失分在分出黑白，老战友的转变突兀。
过气老套，但整体还不是太差，类似《亡命天涯》《生死狙击》的缩水减配剧本，本福斯特适合演纯恶人，这部良心发现就很无聊，至于克里斯派恩，现在已经从好莱坞一线往三线俯冲，而且依然没有刹住的迹象。
抛去各种槽点和漏洞，把世间险恶讲的很清晰，人性够黑暗。
啊？合着搞这么大阴毛就是boss自己的组织？各种逻辑不通，除了派恩还有看头。。。各种蜜汁闪回。。。唉，好了好了，我知道你们美帝退役特种兵都不容易，不如来天朝当个UP主？
4.9/10 即便剧本与同类型有极高的重合度, 但若活用题材与设定, 本可完成一本颇具思考价值的剧本。 可惜故事内容过满只得压缩, 可压缩之后故事又欠缺逻辑与条理。 并且本作更为致命的部分, 在于这个故事的深度与复杂度, 使场面不得不让位于叙事。 尽管动作戏观赏性极其优秀, 但简短的时长未能使其掩盖住剧本的不足。 最终以剧本与场面互相牵制的状态, 奉上一部失误满满的影片。
剧情没啥逻辑，文戏也没啥推动剧情的意义。也就柏林枪战有点意思。
满满的好莱坞味道，情节虽然老套，处处模仿好莱坞，但模仿得真的还不错，合格的宝莱坞爆米花，剧情核心就是，别人有的我们印度也有，而且更好。
前面鋪墊略長，最後隊友在主角救兩次之後還是掛了，太慘了。本可以不死的。自己不覺得自己離譜嗎？是應景了，可戰場下來的在那大大咧咧看傷口？戰術動作全忘了？喝個啤酒看個樂呵吧，這個結尾的槍戰顯得有點草率了。
6.5分。跑到另一个国家去当街开火，敢这么干的除了美国佬的确是没谁了。问题是主角都已经去干黑活了，还要加个所谓的拯救世界的由头干嘛？？这点觉悟都没吗？偏真实向的枪战场面还算不错，其他么就没啥可看的了。
从柏林街头无脑射杀男主开始，情节就一路崩。疫苗那个线索毫无作用，最后都不知道怎么处理的。动作戏份还停留在十几年前，没有大场面，最后决战跟过家家似的，连个能打的都没有。
故事不吸引人。情节展开缓慢。如果跟杰森伯恩比，那表演基本一个天上一个地上。打斗场面很差。没啥娱乐性。再加上美式救赎方式，基本没法看。
一星给男主演技，二星给枪战现场布置，三星给影射的现实
（印度）科幻超级英雄电影，精英战士受伤瘫痪，获得最新科技“超算AI”加持，变身超级战士，奇兵降临势如破竹，一人搞定恐怖团伙几乎所有几十号人马，拯救了一群高级政客和许多群众。宝莱坞对标“漫威\DC”的超英电影，合格。宝莱坞还在路上，有点猛。
另外我看的120分钟不到，这个里面写怎么有130分钟。。。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
